Nobody asked me, but here’s my solutions.

{EAV_BLOG_VER:8aaff7272ea0fbbf}
One criticism I often have of others is that they critique ideas without offering any of their own. It’s easy to take pot shots at others or to simply say no on philosophical grounds without any other justifications.

Some people talk about government being too big, we have too many regulations, government is the problem – not the solution, they say. They are willing to risk throwing out the baby with the bathwater so to speak. They see government as corrupt, evil and fundamentally flawed. While very few will offer specific examples.

Others, like myself, recognize that there are serious problems with our government, as there is with any government. But there is a proper place and role that government is necessary for a functioning society based on the rule of law and compassion for our fellow man.

Our country is divided in so many other ways; right vs left, urban vs rural, haves vs have nots, old vs young, religious vs secular, and many more less obvious and stark. But we are all Americans and we’re in this thing together. We can either rip this country apart because of our differences, or we can come together to make this country greater than ever.

We’re facing a lot of problems, unemployment, the deficit, the economy as a whole, immigration, the war against terrorism, the war on drugs, crisis in education and healthcare – it’s easy to get overwhelmed by them all. I think many people are scared, angry, confused, frustrated, they are looking for someone to blame, looking for quick and easy solutions. There are those that are capitalizing on that to benefit and enrich themselves. Others are using it to attack and destroy others.

There is a saying that “Money is the root of all evil”. When we look at our most pressing problems we can see that money is certainly a major component of them all in one way or another. So it would make sense that if money is the problem, money is also the solution.

Right now the problems are being approached independently of one another. The solutions offered are limited. Raise or lower taxes. Cut or increase government spending. Basically its fighting over a finite amount of pie. We need to change our focus, we need to bake a bigger pie.

In a previous post I asked the question: “What Kind Of Country Do We Want?“. Much of it was written based on the finite pie scenario. However, no matter how large the pie, we’re going to need to have priorities, certain values that are non-negotiable. For me, and for the purposes of this discussion that means we take care of our elderly, disabled, sick, unemployed and veterans. We value eduction, equal opportunity, self reliance, entrepreneurship, personal liberty, independence and freedom.

Each of my proposals will, save money or increase revenue and adhere to the values and priorities above.

  1. Remove the cap on income subject to Social Security tax. It may be possible to lower the rate, which would lessen the impact on upper income earners, and provide some relief for lower incomer earners and the self employed who have to pay both the employer and employee portions of the tax.
  2. Add a Public Option for health care that will allow anyone to buy into a health insurance plan on a sliding scale. This would virtually eliminate society cost of the uninsured using the most expensive health care, emergency rooms, for routine health care that could have been averted with preventative care, or taking care of at a less expensive medical provider, such as a doctor’s office or clinic.
  3. Remove most restrictions to enter the country legally for the purpose of work. Would have to pass criminal background check. Would not be eligible for public assistance. Required to buy into public option health insurance, if not covered by employer. Would be required to pay all taxes. Persons already in the country would be eligible if they clear criminal background check.
  4. Employers to be held strictly accountable to ensure all of their employees were eligible to work legally in the country. Requirement would include having picture ID issued by the State or Federal Government on file at all times. Immigrant employees must be paid the same, have same benefits, same working conditions and hours as citizen employees. Violations would result in heavy fines and jail time for employers.
  5. End all corporate and farm subsidies for products or services to be sold overseas. Subsidies may still provided on in country sales to value added companies. Also end all subsidies and incentives for outsourcing jobs.
  6. Remove Hemp from the list of controlled substances. Ban the export of non-value added Hemp. Then get out of the way and let American entrepreneurial spirit take hold to create new products from this natural renewable resource.
  7. Transfer the federal regulation of Marijuana to the ATF to be renamed MATF. License, regulate and tax similar to existing Tobacco and Alcohol operations. States would have the same rights to license, regulate and tax in their jurisdictions.
  8. Pardon and release all persons currently being held for simple marijuana possession.
  9. Expand Job Corps with funds saved from not arresting, prosecuting and incarcerating marijuana users. Add training needed in the manufacturing of the 1000′s of products being made from Hemp.
  10. Make child support payments tax deductible. The more non-custodial parents pay the less dependent single parents will be on State benefits.
  11. End the Bush tax cuts for the top 2% income earners. Tax all income the same regardless of the source. End the Hedge Fund “carried interest” windfall loophole

So there you go. Have at it. Rip up my ideas, but come with your own. I’m prepared to defend my ideas, so be prepared to defend your criticisms and your ideas.

Be Sociable, Share!
  • Lmack49

    First, the quote “money is the root of all evil” is not correctly stated. It was not money, but “the love of money that is the root of all evil” I Tim. 6:10. Changing the emphasis from “money” to the “love of money” changes the whole understanding of the discussion. It is not those who possess money that posses evil, but those who love and pursue money that posses evil. Having money is not necessary to be guilty of this vice but simply having an unnatural desire for money. Such a desire for the wealth of others involves envy and lust and the same religious system that produced the quote above is critical of such inordinate desire.

    Government solutions require that humans be put in charge of making decisions that affect large numbers of people. The rub comes when large sums of money are involved corruption enters. Evil and corruption can’t be removed from the process it makes no difference which party is in office. Since the Reagan Administration, it has been proved that Presidents and high government officials are relative immune to criminal investigation and prosecution. Reagan, Clinton, and GW Bush and now Obama all have issues that some wanted them held accountable for, and it will not happen. Presidents, cabinet members, presidential staff, and members of congress are relative immune to prosecution, but not entirely (The further removed from the elected official, the less the immunity). These are the last people we want to be putting in charge of making decisions for that we can make for ourselves.

    Comments on your list are as follows:
    1. Socialist Security often mispronounced in the media as Sos-Security to remove any connection to true origins of the program should be renamed Socialist Insecurity. It was a doomed program from the beginning. The agenda of the Humanist to limit population growth over the past 80 years has changed our society to the point that we are not having children and the same rate as prior to 1960. Baby Bloomers are not having the large families of previous generations. Now our aging population tends to outnumber the producers. Sure we can increase the take using some revised taxing scheme, but it will bankrupt the younger generation to service the program. The Social Security train wreck coming is not going to end well for anyone. The longer we wait to dismantle the program, the worse the wreck will be. So many of us have paid into the program and would like to get at least our investment back. Not going to happen. Funny thing, if I had invested the same amount of money into a bank at even 6% interest, I would now be a multi-millionaire and the money would be mine. As it is raising the retirement age is being discussed and cost of living raises have been canceled by this and previous administrations, all to keep my investment to try to make the program solvent. I and my heirs will not see all my investment and what ever is left at my death will be kept by the government. The entire program should be dismantled.
    2. Health care should remain in the hands of the people. Our system has worked fine for 100′s of years. Socialized medicine has failed every time it has been tried. Do we think we as Americans can do it better than the Germans, the Brits, or the Canadians? NO we do worse with government programs than any of these. The administration is already discussing the implementation of death panels for the elderly and unproductive to save on health care cost. Tort reform, a level playing field, and deregulation of the health care industry will do the job. We already see the best health care moving to Eastern Europe where medical practice is free of government mandates and interference. Get ready for years of waiting just to get “emergency surgery” as it now is in Canada and England.
    3. On immigration and temporary workers we agree. Why can’t a program be put into place to process foreign workers and make them legal when entering the country? The undocumented workers move under the radar and work without paying income tax, social security tax, etc and unfairly compete with our own people who must pay the taxes. Moving away from the income tax and using a VAT tax would help the situation, but would not entirely solve the problem. These undocumented workers enter the country using schools, roads, hospitals, etc straining the system but nothing is collected from them to cover the cost. The current arrangement is not fair to the existing legal residents who have no choice but to pay for these items via taxation hence the anger at illegal aliens and undocumented workers. Moving tax collection away from the federal government and allowing local and state governments to devise funding methods from within would also tend to solve the problem.
    4. Agree in total, but you will run afoul of the bleeding hearts who totally oppose this arrangement.
    5. Right on!!!
    6. Naaah! No on the Mari-gee-wanna! It damages brains . . . and places people on welfare rolls. Do away with welfare and socialized medicine and I might be with you.
    7. See 6.
    8. See 6.
    9. See 6.
    10. Wow! Tax breaks tend to help society! Makes one wonder why 11 is necessary at all. I do not like the idea of “targeted tax breaks” used extensively in the current income tax system. The tax system should neither encourage nor discourage child production. See government corruption above. Allowing elected officials to make this kind of decision will always result in decisions being made to benefit the elected official party notwithstanding.
    11. See the last sentence above. The entire tax system needs to be revised to remove the burden of tax collection and payment from the individual. A uniform across the board “flat” income tax or a federal “VAT” would be acceptable. Tax would be collected on all wages or transactions by the employer or vendor who would be totally responsible for payment as is now the case with state run “VAT” programs. Think of the resources saved if all individuals could be removed from paying any federal taxes directly. The program would work to the extent that the more you work, the more you pay or the more you spend the more you pay. Individuals would not even have to keep records. I would love it! All record keeping would be required by employers or merchants who already have to keep similar records. It would not increase the burden on business. China does not even collect tax on “Capital Gains” and their investment program is booming. We could learn from them.

    It was amazing on how many things we agree, Mari-gee-wanna notwithstanding. I am afraid that too many people believe that the government can solve all our problems. Government is made up of people. The more people the more the corruption. Another wise saying was “Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely”. Government solutions should be the last to be considered for any problem.

  • http://allalaskans.com/emperor/ emperor

    Thanks for the well thought out response. I appreciate you taking the time to do so.

    Regardless of the original source or context of the quote, I believe the premise of money being the root of all is still valid. That doesn’t mean to say that money itself is evil, or that money can’t also be a source of good.

    The problems of fraud, abuse, waste and corruption always has been and always will be part and parcel of government at all levels. You find it in the the smallest rural communities and at the highest reaches of government. Smaller government is no guaranteed solution to criminal behavior and greed. In my opinion, a more effective way to approach those problems is by Radical campaign finance and election reform

    Response by topic.

    1. Social Security

    You’re obviously philosophically opposed to the very idea of Social Security. An American value that shall not be abandoned as I stated above is “we take care of our elderly, disabled…”. Eliminating or cutting Social Security is simply not an option to be considered. We can’t solve the country’s financial problems on the backs of the most vulnerable.

    According to the most recent actuary report from Social Security and Medicare Boards of Trustees

    “Conclusion:

    The ACA makes significant progress toward making Medicare financially viable. But while it is projected that the Medicare HI Trust Fund is adequately financed until 2029, and the Social Security OASI and DI Trust Funds are adequately financed until 2040 and 2018, respectively, the significant longer term financial imbalances of the programs still need to be addressed. The sooner action is taken to address the long-run financial imbalances, the more reform options will be available, and the more time there will be to phase in changes so that those affected will have adequate time to prepare.”

    So, collapse of the system is neither imminent nor unavoidable. By eliminating the cap, expanding the economy and the number of people paying into the system, the long term solvency of the programs will be assured. Immigration is the alternative to families having fewer children.

    2. Health Care.

    Our health care system works for the rich and those fortunate enough to have health insurance. The number of companies providing health insurance is dwindling. The cost of health insurance is skyrocketing as is the cost of health care itself. The lack of access to preventative health care, early detection and treatment is costing us billions of dollars. Doing nothing about our health care system is not a solution.

    U.S. Health Care Costs: Background Brief – KaiserEDU.org, Health Policy Education from the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation

    “Option” is the key. It’s still insurance you pay for. If you want to keep your current insurance there is nothing preventing you from doing so.

    3. Immigration

    A system to allow immigrants to enter the country for the purpose of working would be fairly easy to implement. Take their picture, finger prints and DNA. Run a background check. Once cleared they would be issued a card permitting them entry and the ability to work legally in the US.

    Undocumented workers do pay taxes. Most local, county, state taxes are sales and property taxes. Undocumented workers are not excluded from those. Many pay up at tax time including Social Security, Medicare and Unemployment that they aren’t qualified to receive.

    Sales taxes (VAT) are regressive by nature and hurt the working poor the most. Adding additional point of sale taxes on top of existing local sales taxes would only hurt sales.

    4. Employer accountability.

    I think when tied to making it easier for immigrants to register to work legally, most people would agree with this. I think there would be more resistance from the business community because they hate any government intrusion into their businesses, and certainly don’t want to have to treat all their workers equally.

    5. Corporate subsidies.

    Another point that will be a tough sale to the business community. They are all for making individuals take the blunt of the blow for economic downturns, but they fight every inch to preserve their special perks.

    6. Hemp is not Marijuana. You can’t get stoned smoking it.

    7,8,9 Marijuana

    I’m sorry, but you’re flat wrong on all counts about Marijuana. It’s far less damaging than alcohol. Has proven medical uses. Users are usually non-violent. Societal cost of Marijuana use is much lower than alcohol or tobacco. Marijuana smuggling is the number one reason for violence amongst the Mexican drug cartels. We are spending billions of dollars enforcing, prosecuting, and incarcerating people for possession of a plant. Not only would legalization save billions, it would produce billions in tax revenues at every level of government. These are the same reasons that prohibition was ended. Government needed a new source of revenue during the depression.

    For someone who objects so much about the interference of government in peoples lives, your objection to Marijuana legalization seems out of character and inconsistent.

    10. Child Support.

    Usually the parent with physical custody of a child gets the tax exemption for taxes purposes unless. In an ideal world there would be no need for this kind of thing. I don’t particularly like using the tax code to modify behavior, but in this case I think we need a carrot along with the stick.

    11. Taxes.

    I’m all for a flat tax, from first dollar to last dollar regardless of source. We’ll never get that past the millionaires or corporations that love all the ways available to them to lower or even eliminate paying any federal income taxes.

    Again, I really appreciate your response and look forward to continuing the discussion.

  • http://emperorbob.com Emperor_Bob

    Thanks for the well thought out response. I appreciate you taking the time to do so.

    Regardless of the original source or context of the quote, I believe the premise of money being the root of all is still valid. That doesn’t mean to say that money itself is evil, or that money can’t also be a source of good.

    The problems of fraud, abuse, waste and corruption always has been and always will be part and parcel of government at all levels. You find it in the the smallest rural communities and at the highest reaches of government. Smaller government is no guaranteed solution to criminal behavior and greed. In my opinion, a more effective way to approach those problems is by Radical campaign finance and election reform

    Response by topic.

    1. Social Security

    You’re obviously philosophically opposed to the very idea of Social Security. An American value that shall not be abandoned as I stated above is “we take care of our elderly, disabled…”. Eliminating or cutting Social Security is simply not an option to be considered. We can’t solve the country’s financial problems on the backs of the most vulnerable.

    According to the most recent actuary report from Social Security and Medicare Boards of Trustees

    “Conclusion:

    The ACA makes significant progress toward making Medicare financially viable. But while it is projected that the Medicare HI Trust Fund is adequately financed until 2029, and the Social Security OASI and DI Trust Funds are adequately financed until 2040 and 2018, respectively, the significant longer term financial imbalances of the programs still need to be addressed. The sooner action is taken to address the long-run financial imbalances, the more reform options will be available, and the more time there will be to phase in changes so that those affected will have adequate time to prepare.”

    So, collapse of the system is neither imminent nor unavoidable. By eliminating the cap, expanding the economy and the number of people paying into the system, the long term solvency of the programs will be assured. Immigration is the alternative to families having fewer children.

    2. Health Care.

    Our health care system works for the rich and those fortunate enough to have health insurance. The number of companies providing health insurance is dwindling. The cost of health insurance is skyrocketing as is the cost of health care itself. The lack of access to preventative health care, early detection and treatment is costing us billions of dollars. Doing nothing about our health care system is not a solution.

    U.S. Health Care Costs: Background Brief – KaiserEDU.org, Health Policy Education from the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation

    “Option” is the key. It’s still insurance you pay for. If you want to keep your current insurance there is nothing preventing you from doing so.

    3. Immigration

    A system to allow immigrants to enter the country for the purpose of working would be fairly easy to implement. Take their picture, finger prints and DNA. Run a background check. Once cleared they would be issued a card permitting them entry and the ability to work legally in the US.

    Undocumented workers do pay taxes. Most local, county, state taxes are sales and property taxes. Undocumented workers are not excluded from those. Many pay up at tax time including Social Security, Medicare and Unemployment that they aren’t qualified to receive.

    Sales taxes (VAT) are regressive by nature and hurt the working poor the most. Adding additional point of sale taxes on top of existing local sales taxes would only hurt sales.

    4. Employer accountability.

    I think when tied to making it easier for immigrants to register to work legally, most people would agree with this. I think there would be more resistance from the business community because they hate any government intrusion into their businesses, and certainly don’t want to have to treat all their workers equally.

    5. Corporate subsidies.

    Another point that will be a tough sale to the business community. They are all for making individuals take the blunt of the blow for economic downturns, but they fight every inch to preserve their special perks.

    6. Hemp is not Marijuana. You can’t get stoned smoking it.

    7,8,9 Marijuana

    I’m sorry, but you’re flat wrong on all counts about Marijuana. It’s far less damaging than alcohol. Has proven medical uses. Users are usually non-violent. Societal cost of Marijuana use is much lower than alcohol or tobacco. Marijuana smuggling is the number one reason for violence amongst the Mexican drug cartels. We are spending billions of dollars enforcing, prosecuting, and incarcerating people for possession of a plant. Not only would legalization save billions, it would produce billions in tax revenues at every level of government. These are the same reasons that prohibition was ended. Government needed a new source of revenue during the depression.

    For someone who objects so much about the interference of government in peoples lives, your objection to Marijuana legalization seems out of character and inconsistent.

    10. Child Support.

    Usually the parent with physical custody of a child gets the tax exemption for taxes purposes unless. In an ideal world there would be no need for this kind of thing. I don’t particularly like using the tax code to modify behavior, but in this case I think we need a carrot along with the stick.

    11. Taxes.

    I’m all for a flat tax, from first dollar to last dollar regardless of source. We’ll never get that past the millionaires or corporations that love all the ways available to them to lower or even eliminate paying any federal income taxes.

    Again, I really appreciate your response and look forward to continuing the discussion.

  • Pingback: The Emperor Speaks « The Altered States of Munley